Other countries have called for wealth tax. South Africa should follow suit argues the writer.
Image: AFP
The debate surrounding the wealth tax has reached a boiling point in recent political developments, and the stance taken by prominent figures and organizations is increasingly telling. The fact that the DA, which represents the liberal wing of South Africa’s political spectrum, and the Helen Suzman Foundation, a key defender of free market principles, have both voiced opposition to the wealth tax speaks volumes.
But what does this opposition signal to us as a society? It serves as a stark reminder that the wealthiest in this country are deeply entrenched in a system that ensures their continued dominance. However, right-wing parties are not the only ones challenging wealth tax proposals; right-wing elements within the ANC are also vocal in their opposition.
This political division calls for a strong and united left-wing response. Those of us on the left must unite within and outside of the ANC to fight for policies like the wealth tax that directly challenge the power of the ruling capitalist class. If we are serious about transforming South Africa into a more equitable society, the time to act is now. The opposition to the wealth tax is not just a disagreement over policy; it’s an attempt to protect the existing structures of wealth and privilege that benefit a select few while leaving the majority of South Africans in poverty.
The wealth tax threatens the core interests of the wealthy elite. As the party representing the business establishment, the DA is naturally opposed to any policy that could redistribute wealth from the rich to the poor. However, the Helen Suzman Foundation, which promotes liberalism and free market ideologies, also opposes the measure. Their concern centers on the idea that a wealth tax could stifle investment and entrepreneurship.
Yet, we must ask ourselves: Whose interests do these organizations genuinely represent? The fact that both the DA and the Helen Suzman Foundation are so opposed to the wealth tax suggests that they are aligned with the status quo — a system where the ultra-rich remain untouchable and insulated from the struggles faced by ordinary South Africans. They advocate for a system perpetuating inequality, arguing that wealth should remain in the hands of a few individuals and families who control the lion’s share of resources. But what is the alternative? A tax system that continues to benefit the wealthy while the majority of the population languishes in poverty? We cannot accept this. The country’s wealth gap is alarming, with dire social and economic consequences. The call for a wealth tax is not about penalizing success; it is about ensuring that those who have amassed their fortunes through centuries of exploitation contribute their fair share to the well-being of the society that allowed them to accumulate their wealth in the first place.
The problem lies with the opposition from the DA and the Helen Suzman Foundation and the internal divisions within the ANC. There are right-wing elements within the ANC who are aligned with the interests of the capitalist class and are vehemently against any form of redistribution of wealth. These individuals often speak in the language of economic growth and job creation. Still, their actions consistently protect the interests of the powerful rather than addressing the needs of the poor and marginalized. If we are serious about achieving real change, we must confront the forces within the ANC that are working to maintain the status quo.
The party's left wing must unite, standing firm in its commitment to policies that challenge the entrenched power structures. The wealth tax must become a rallying point for this unity. The working class and poor in South Africa cannot afford to be left behind by leaders who are too cozy with the wealthy elite. The Capitalist ParasitesOne of the most glaring contradictions in the South African economy is the prevalence of so-called entrepreneurs who possess no specialized skills but make their fortunes by relying on government tenders. These individuals, who often form part of the so-called "tenderpreneur" class, are emblematic of the problem with South Africa’s economic system.
They exploit government contracts and public resources without contributing value to society. They rely on a system rigged in their favor, using political connections and access to state resources to build their wealth rather than contributing meaningfully to the country’s development. This phenomenon is not just a moral issue; it’s a systemic one. The wealth that these tenderpreneurs accumulate is built on the backs of ordinary South Africans who are forced to pay for goods and services that are overpriced and under-delivered.
This is not entrepreneurship; it is parasitism. The wealth these individuals accumulate does not represent actual value creation; it represents the perpetuation of a system where the poor subsidize the rich. We must reject this kind of capitalism, which benefits a small elite at the expense of the vast majority of South Africans. A wealth tax would be a step in the right direction, forcing these parasitic individuals and corporations to pay their fair share of taxes, which could then be reinvested in public services that benefit most of the population.
A Call for Left UnityIf the left in South Africa is to stand a chance in pushing for the wealth tax, it must unite. This unity must transcend party lines, bringing together progressive forces within and outside the ANC. We can not afford to let the right-wing forces that dominate the political landscape continue to dictate the terms of the debate. The wealth tax is not just a matter of fiscal policy but a matter of justice. It is about confronting the deeply entrenched economic inequalities that continue to divide our society. We must recognize that the struggle for the wealth tax is part of a larger fight for economic and social justice in South Africa. It is a fight against a system that rewards the rich while exploiting the poor. It is a fight for a new economic order that prioritizes the needs of the many over the interests of the few. The fight can only be won if the left comes together, united in its commitment to building a more just and equitable society. The battle for the wealth tax is not just a political struggle but a moral imperative. We must reject the forces of greed and inequality and fight for a future in which the country's wealth is shared more equitably. The time to act is now, and the left must stand together to ensure the voices of the poor and marginalized are heard. The wealth tax is a critical step toward achieving that goal, and we must fight for it with all our might.
*Mayalo is an independent writer, analyst, and commentator
** *The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the views of IOL or Independent Media.